Halaman
CHAPTER 5
Benefit of Doubt
90
Kelas XI SMA/MA/SMK/MAK
Semester 1
CHAPTER 5
Personal Connection
Have you ever faced a situation in which all odds were against you but
you had unflinching faith in God and believed that everything will be
resolved? Write about this situation and describe your feelings. If you
want, you can share what you have written with your classmates and
teacher.
Genre Connection
Personal letter is a type of letter which usually concerns personal matters
and is sent from one individual to another. Personal letters have been a
popular form of communication between people for a long time. People
used to take pride in writing letters as it was considered an art in itself but
due to recent technological advances the art of letter writing has been
replaced by emails and short messages (Bly, 2004).
Famous letter writers:
Ernest Hemmingway
John Steinbeck
Georgia O' Keeffe
Juliette Adam
Raden Ajeng Kartini
In this chapter you will:
- Read a short story
- Learn to write a personal letter
- Write a letter
- Create a skit
- Illustrate a scene from the story
Prereading Activities
91
Benefit of Doubt
Bahasa Inggris
Reading Activity
Letter to
GOD
Rancho's house – the
lone house in the entire valley – was on
the crown of a low hill. From the
pinnacle of the hill one could see the
rapid flowing stream and next to it vast
fields of ripe corn in between the red
kidney bean flowers. Looking at it one
could predict that it was going to be
good harvest but it needed a rainfall,
however brief.
All through the morning Rancho kept scanning the sky for signs of rainfall and he
was quite confident that it would rain. “
You know, woman,
now we are finally
going to get some rain.”
His wife, who was busy preparing food, replied:
“Yes, God
willing.”
As soon as Rancho's family, his wife and sons, sat for dinner, just as he had
predicted big drops of rain started falling. In the Northeast huge clouds were
covering the sky like a blanket. The air had the smell of rain combined with the
smell of fresh earth. The atmosphere at that time was absolutely heavenly. The
boys left their food on pretext of getting one thing and another. All they wanted
was to get wet and play in the rain.
Rancho was very happy as he looked at his field,
“Ah! now my harvest is
going to be wonderful.”
He started dreaming about all the things he will be doing
once he sells the crops. Suddenly heavy winds began to blow accompanied by big
drops of rain, which looked like huge pearls of ice.
“Oh my God! This can't be
happening,”
he thought.
“NO!! NO!! I will be destroyed. This is no rain, it is a
hailstorm. I hope it will pass soon.”
But in front of his family he kept a strong front
and said, “
I am sure it will pass soon, don't worry.”
Unfortunately it didn't. The hailstorm lasted the whole night. It destroyed
entire field of his precious crops. Everything looked so white as if someone had
thrown sacks and sacks of pearls all over the place.
Picture 5.1 (Source: Kemendikbud)
92
Kelas XI SMA/MA/SMK/MAK
Semester 1
Rancho and his wife were worried to death. Everything they had was destroyed
and they had no inkling as to what they will do.
The boys asked them,
“What are we going to do? Everything is destroyed.
We don't even have few pieces of corn or beans. Does this mean we are going to die
of hunger?”
Rancho said,
“ My sons, nobody dies of hunger. Always remember we have
God. I am sure he will help us.”
All through the night Rancho kept on thinking how to ask for help from
God.
“God knows everything but I think I should write to Him and ask directly what I
want.”
Rancho was thankful for the day his parents had sent him to school. Even
though he wasn't interested in studies but he had grudgingly learned to read and
write. So he took out paper and pen and started writing.
Rancho Lucas
The Violet Hill
Argentina
th
18 May 1999
Dear God
Hi,
I am writing this letter to you out of extreme urgency, otherwise I
wouldn't have disturbed you. You know about the recent hailstorm in
my place. Well, it has destroyed me. Everything in my farm was
destroyed. My corn and kidney beans were almost ready and all it
needed was a rainfall but instead of rainfall came a storm. If it had
lasted for short period it would have been OK, but unfortunately it
lasted for an entire night. It has put me at a serious disadvantage, you
see God, my sole source of income is that farm and now it is
completely destroyed. Nothing is left. If I leave it like this my family
will die of hunger, since we will not have anything to eat. I can't sit
still and do nothing about it. I need 100 pesos to buy the seeds and
resow my field all over again and buy some food till the next harvest.
So dear God, please help me. I know you will not disappoint me.
Sincerely Yours,
Rancho, the farmer
93
Bahasa Inggris
th
He put the letter inside an envelope and addressed it to
“God, 7 Heaven”
and placed a stamp on it and dropped it in the mailbox. The workers at the post
office were preparing the letters to mail when they came across the letter
addressed to God. The postman who came across this letter became curious
because he had never seen a letter addressed to God. He wanted to open the
letter but his job ethics stopped him from doing so. He decided to take the letter to
the Postmaster. The Postmaster was a very nice and kind gentleman. He always
helped people in any way he could. When the postman gave him the letter, he
looked at it and said,
“It takes a man with strong faith to start a communication
with God. I wish I had such strong faith.”
After much thought, he decided to read the letter and perhaps reply it. He
opened Rancho's letter. Little did he know that replying the letter would need
more than good intention, pen and paper. Rancho needed a lot of money but the
postmaster didn't have any. Since he had already decided to help Rancho, he
decided to give part of his salary, and he asked his friends and co-workers to
contribute. But it was impossible for him to collect 100 pesos. He was happy that at
least 70 pesos were collected. So he put the money in an envelope and signed it as
“God” and asked the postman to deliver it to Rancho's house.
When the postman arrived at Rancho's house and delivered the letter to
him, Rancho was exhilarated beyond means. And he kept repeating Thank you
God! Thank you God! I knew you wouldn't let me down.
Rancho had very strong faith in God. He was not surprised when he
opened the envelope. But as he was counting the money he became very angry.
God couldn't have made mistake in sending the money. So he took out paper and
wrote to God again. Then he placed a stamp on it and put it in the mailbox. When
the postman took the letter out, he immediately took it to the postmaster. The
Postmaster quickly opened the letter and everyone in the post office gathered
around him wanting to know what Rancho wrote to God.
Rancho Lucas
The Violet Hill
Argentina
th
20 May 1999
Dear God
I am really grateful to you for sending the money. I knew you wouldn't let my family
go hungry. Of the money you send me I only received 70 pesos. Please send me the
rest. I really need the money. But, this time please, God don't send it through the
mail, because the people working here in this post office are all a bunch of thieves.
94
Kelas XI SMA/MA/SMK/MAK
Semester 1
Read the questions carefully. Note down your opinions and reactions to the
questions. During the discussion with your teacher and classmates, offer your
personal reaction and understanding of the text.
1. Do you think it is important to have faith? Why? Give reasons to support
your answer.
2. Do you think it was justified on Rancho's part to consider the post office
employees as bunch of thieves? Discuss.
3. Do you think Rancho did the right thing by asking God for help? Discuss.
4. When people go through difficult times, they come out of difficult times
stronger and more experienced. Do you think it is God's way of
empowering people to fulfill the life's purpose on earth? Discuss and give
reasons to support you answer.
5. What do you think of Rancho? Do you sympathize with him and his
family? Discuss.
6. Did you anticipate that the story would end like this? What were your
thoughts about the ending?
7. We always pray to God asking for His help. Describe a time when you
asked God for something but HE answered your prayer in a way you had
not anticipated. How did you feel? Were you happy the way things turned
out to be?
8. If you had a chance to rewrite the story, how would the story end? Write a
new ending of the story?
Sincerely yours
Rancho, the farmer
(Inspired from “Una carta a Dios” by Por Gregorio López y Fuente)
95
Bahasa Inggris
PERSONAL
JOURNAL WRITING
Choose one of the topics to reflect and write your diary on:
- What would you do if you were in Postmaster's place?
- If you were the Postmaster, what would be your reaction after
reading the second letter?
96
Kelas XI SMA/MA/SMK/MAK
Semester 1
Personal Letter
Personal letters are the letters that are written to people we know such as
friends, parents, siblings, cousins. Letters are not only written to inform but
to strengthen the bond between two people writing to each other.
Expressions
Some useful expressions for letter writing
Gratitude
- I'm just writing to thank you for ............
- It was very kind of you to ............
- Thanks very much for ............
- I am very grateful for ............
Giving advice
- Well, I thought about it and if I were you, I would ............
- Have you thought about ............
- In your last letter you said you weren't sure what course of action to
take, I suggest ............
- I think you shouldn't ............
- In your last letter you asked me about .............., I think ...............
Types
of
Letters
Informal letter
also known as
personal letter
Formal letter
97
Bahasa Inggris
Structure of Personal Letter
Date when the letter is written (top left).
The opening of the letter usually starts with
how are you or refers to previous letter.
Date
Introduction
Place where you are writing from (top right).
Address
Salutation & Name
Greeting and the person's name you are writing to
The main part of the letter. It includes what you
want to write to the other person.
Body
The part indicates the letter is going to end.
Closure
Delivering good news
- I'm sure you will be happy to hear that ............
- I am sure that you'll be interested to know that ............
- By the way, did you know that ............ ?
- OMG!! You'll never guess what happened!
- I am totally ecstatic to hear about ............
- I was happy beyond limits to read that ............
Delivering bad news
- I'm sorry but I have to tell you that ............
- Bad news, I'm afraid but no way to avoid it, so here it goes ............
- I'm extremely sorry to hear that ............
- It was heart wrenching to read about ............
Asking for help
- I wonder if you could help me.
- I hope it's not too much to ask but ............
- I wonder if I could ask you a favor. Could you ............?
Apologizing
- I would like to apologize for ............
- I'm so sorry that ............
- Words are not enough to erase the pain I have given you but I want to
say how sorry I am ............
98
Kelas XI SMA/MA/SMK/MAK
Semester 1
Examples of expressions used in personal letters
Salutations
Closing
Starting the letter
Conclusion
“Dear”, “Dearest”, “sweetheart”, “darling”, “My
dear”, “My love” etc.
Salutations depend on how well you know the
person you are writing to.
“Yours”, “with love”, “sincerely yours”, “all the
love”, “all the best”, “affectionately”, “much love”,
“best wishes”
How are you?
Hope this letter finds you......
Thank you for your last letter.
It was so good to hear from you.
Sorry for answering late.
I'm sorry I should have written earlier........
Haven't heard from you in a while so I thought .....
I am sorry to inform you that......
I am looking forward to seeing you soon.
I am looking forward to hearing from you soon.
My best wishes for the coming test.
See you.
I will write soon.
I will have to stop now.
I am waiting for a quick reply.
Looking forward to seeing you again.
Bye.
Signature or initials of the writer.
Signature
Postscript P.S.
After thought in a letter. You begin with P.S. and
end it with your initials.
Short expressions like “love you”, “sincerely
yours”, “love”.
Complimentary close
99
Bahasa Inggris
Language in personal letter
Sentence
structure
- Accuracy of grammar is important.
- Complete sentences are expected.
- Slang can be used.
- Use Contractions such as
“I'll”, “ I'm”, “we'll”.
-
Use personal pronouns such as
“I”, “we”, “you”.
-
Use active voice.
Style:
- Language use may be personal like first and second person
pronouns.
- Be warm.
- Use person's name you are writing to.
- Vary sentence length.
- Write in a natural, conversational style.
- Let your personality shine through in your writing.
(Bly, 2004).
World’s longest letter
In 1952, a lady in Brooklyn, USA
wrote a letter using narrow
tape. She used 3.200 feet of the
narrow tape. It took her one
month to write the letter.
World’s shortest letter
In 1862, Victor Hugo wanted to
know how his book “Les
Miserables” was selling.
He wrote to his publisher:
“?”
The publisher replied:
“!”
K N OW
DID YOU
?
100
Kelas XI SMA/MA/SMK/MAK
Semester 1
Example of a personal letter
35 Senggigi Raya
Lombok
75009 Nusa Tenggara Timur
th
12 January 2014
My Dear Lovely Siti,
Hello!
How are you, sweetie? I know you are angry with me because I
am writing to you after a long time. I am so sorry, please forgive me.
You know we are in Lombok right now. It is so beautiful beyond
imagination. I am writing to you from this really cute little café on the
Senggigi beach. As you know, mum loves shopping so she went and
will be gone for hours. I took a rain check from shopping and decided
to write to you while I enjoy my cup of coffee.
You know yesterday we went to Gili Nanggu Island; it is a beach
on the southwest of Lombok. The place is awesome. It is so beautiful I
couldn't believe my eyes. There are beautiful coral reefs everywhere.
We went for snorkeling and we saw most amazing fish ever. I wish you
were here; it would have been much more fun.
Mum's making sure we don't miss any sight in the whole city,
so we've practically been everywhere.
I got to go, mum is here. I will see you soon.
Lots of love
XOXO
Lana
P.S. I'm bringing you lot of souvenirs and pictures!!
Address
Date
The Con
tent of the letter
Closure
Closing
Signature
Postscript
Introduction
Salutation
Greetings
101
Bahasa Inggris
Word Power
entire
pinnacle
rapid
confident
inkling
predict
pretext
hail
absolutely
disillusion
Whole, complete with no part left.
Top pointed piece of a rock or the top
most successful point.
Something that happens at high speed.
Feeling or showing confidence.
A slight knowledge or suspicion.
Estimate something that will happen in
future.
A reason given to justify an action.
Pellets of frozen rain.
Totally with no limitation or restriction.
Disappointment when finding out that
something is not as good as one
believed it to be.
\ɪnˈtʌɪə\
\ˈpɪnək(ə)l\
\ˈrapɪd\
\ˈkɒnfɪd(ə)nt\
\ˈɪ
ŋ
klɪ
ŋ
\
\prɪˈdɪkt\
\ˈpriːtɛkst\
\heɪl\
\ˈabsəluːtli\
\dɪsɪˈl(j)uːʒ(ə)n\
K N OW
DID YOU
?
You can use contractions.
For example: I'm, we've,
they’ll, I’d, etc.
You can use informal
language in personal
letters. For example: gonna,
wanna, xoxo,sweetie, etc.
102
Kelas XI SMA/MA/SMK/MAK
Semester 1
Let’s Practice
A. Look at the phrases and match them with the purpose of letter.
The first one has been done for you.
Jl Cinangka Raya
31 March
2014
Ciputat - Tangerang Selatan
My dearest Lana,
Hey sweetie
I hope all is well with you. It's been a while since you moved to the new city for
college. It is so sad that you are not few houses away anymore. I hope your new
life is going well. It must be exciting living on your own in the hostel college.
Everything is fine here. You know nothing much happens here.
Have you already settled in? When is your college starting? Do you like the place
you are living in? How is the neighborhood? I can't believe you live on boarding. I
will be starting college soon as well but my parents insisted that I live at home.
B. There are several mistakes (grammatical as well as in the format of the letter)
in the letter given below. Highlight the mistakes and then rewrite the letter
properly in the space provided.
To apologize
To share some information
To share good news
st
103
Bahasa Inggris
Anyway, a bunch of us were talking about a reunion in summer holidays. So you
better keep your calendar free. Nothing has been decided so suggestions are
welcome!!!
That reminds me If you need anything let me know. I will gladly help. Have fun
and don’t stay out late. we miss you so much!!!
P.S. I saw your mother the other day she misses you a lot and wishes that you
called more often.
Take care and stay safe. Write as soon as you can.
Love always,
Jane
104
Kelas XI SMA/MA/SMK/MAK
Semester 1
C. Fill in the blanks with words given below:
1. My brother is at the __________________of his career. He is extremely
happy.
2. The students lost the quiz competition in the _________________fire
round.
3. The ______________ valley was flooded.
4. The grade 5 students were curious to know how meteorologists
_______________ the weather.
5. Maria had a perfect___________________ to visit her aunt's house.
6. There is prediction that a heavy _____________storm will come on
Wednesday.
7. I____________________ agree with you on banning smoking in public
places
8. He is the most _________________person I have ever met.
9. When magic tricks are revealed children become _________________.
10. I have absolutely no ________________what you are talking about.
entire, pinnacle, rapid, confident, inkling, predict, absolutely,
pretext, hail, disillusioned
105
Bahasa Inggris
Create dialogue for the one of situations given below. Using role-play approach,
reenact the conversation with your classmates.
Situation No: 1
Situation No: 2
Postmaster wants to convince his immediate subordinates and friends to
contribute money for Rancho.
Active Conversation
:
:
:
:
:
What is this? A letter addressed to GOD. Hahaha... I have to
show this letter to the postmaster.
Yes, what is it?
Post man
Post master
Post man
Post master
Post man
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
Post master
Subordinates
Post master
Friends
Subordinates
Friends
Post master
106
Kelas XI SMA/MA/SMK/MAK
Semester 1
Writing Connection
Choose one of the following activities:
- Write a letter to your friend telling her/him all about your adventures during
your trip to the Bromo mountain. Use the proper letter-writing format you
learnt in the building blocks.
- Write a letter to your uncle telling him about the birthday party you organized
for your grandmother. Use the proper letter-writing format you learnt in the
building blocks.
107
Bahasa Inggris
Choose one of the activities given below:
- Use your imagination and draw a scene, which you think is very important for
the story.
- Use your imagination and write a graphic novel/comic of the story.
- Write a letter to your parents thanking them for everything they have done for
you.
- With a partner, create a skit (a short comical/funny drama) for your favorite
scene from the story “letter to God”. Present it in front of your classmates and
teacher.
- With a partner, create a postage stamp and a letter-writing pad. You can frame
your postage stamp and display it in your class or if you want you can take it to
the local post office and show it to the staff of post office.
Let’s Create/Contribute
K N OW
DID YOU
?
The first postage stamp was
invented by a British teacher in
1840.
The first two stamps were called
Penny Black and Twopence Blue.
Example of postage stamp and letter pad
108
Kelas XI SMA/MA/SMK/MAK
Semester 1
Parent Connection
At home, ask your parents or grandparents how they used to communicate with
people who lived far away. Write this conversation in English and share it with your
classmates and teacher.
109
Bahasa Inggris
My plan to overcome difficulties of this chapter
Definitely
Maybe
No
Not at all
Yes
The story was easy to understand.
I can tell the difference
between formal and personal
letter.
I can write personal letters.
I like writing reflections.
I will continue writing reflections
Formative Assessment
I can do this.
Complete these statements:
1. The most interesting thing I learned in this chapter was ___________
2. The part I enjoyed most was ___________
3. I would like to find more about ___________
4. The hardest part in this chapter was ___________
5. I need to work harder at ___________
Read the statements below and tick ( ) the option that is most applicable to
you.
110
Kelas XI SMA/MA/SMK/MAK
Semester 1
Arrington, David P. (1993).
Understanding and Preventing Bullying. In : M.Tonry
(ed) Crime and Justice (volume 17). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Cohen, Robert. (2002).
Theatre brief version 6th edition,
university of California.
Craig Wendy, Fisch Harel .Yossi A. (2009).
Cross-National Profile Of Bullying And
Victimization Among Adolescents In 40 Countries
. International Journal of
Public Health Volume 54, Issue 2 Supplement, pp 216-224.
Damer, T. Edward (2008).
Attacking Faulty Reasoning: A Practical Guide to Fallacy-
free Arguments.
Cengage Learning.
Decree of the President of the Republic of Indonesia
No. 305 of 1959, dated 28
November 1959.
Emi, Emillia. (2012).
Pendekatan Genre-Based dalam Pengajaran Bahasa Inggris
:
Petunjuk untuk Guru. Bandung: Rizi Press, Indonesia.
E. Safra Jacob. (1998).
Short Story in e.a., The New Encyclopaedia Britannica, 15th
edition
.
Chicago: Micropaedia volume 10.
Gerald J. Alred, et al. (2006).
Handbook of Technical Writing
. Bedford/St. Martin's.
Houston, Stephen D. (2004).
The First Writing: Script Invention as History
and Process
. Cambridge University Press.
how the palm oil industry is cooking the climate
. Greenpeace.org.
http://www.bullyingstatistics.org/content/
facts-on-bullying
.html/retrieved 31st
october 2013.
https://www2.bc.edu/~ebel/
Richter1935.pdf
/retrieved 7th november 2013.
http://indonotes.wordpress.com/tag/
ki-hajar-dewantara
/ retrieved on 25th
october 2013.
http://asrirahayudamai.wordpress.com/2013/04/24/
biografi-singkat-ki-hajar-
dewantara-bapak-pendidikan
/retrieved 25th october 2013.
http://www.tokohindonesia.com/biografi/article/295-pahlawan/1502-
bapak-
pendidikan-nasional
, retrieved on 25th October 2013.
http://www.asianewsnet.net/
news-34263.html
.
Joyce Ben, Busyteachers.org 2012.
Lee, Hermione. (2009).
Biography: A Very Short Introduction
, Oxford: University
Press
Mitchell, Larkin. (1999).
Earliest Egyptian Glyphs
.
Archaeology
.
Archaeological
Institute of America: Volume 52 Number 2, March/ April.
North. J. D. (1988).
Chaucer's Universe
. Oxford: Clarendon.
References
111
Bahasa Inggris
112
Kelas XI SMA/MA/SMK/MAK
Semester 1
Oates Stephen B. (1986).
Biogrpahy as High Adventure
, university of
massachusetts press, Massachusetts.
Peter T, Daniels.(1996).
The Study of Writing Systems, in The World's Writing
Systems.
ed Bright and Daniels. Oxford University Press.
Reuters (2007).
Indonesia Losing Crops
, Fish Stocks to Global Warming, Planet Ark.
Rosinsky M, Natalie. (2008).
Write your own biography
. Minneapolis, USA:
Compass point books.
Richter, Charles F. (1935)
An instrumental Earthquake Magnitude scale
, Bulletin of
Seismological Society of America Vol. 25 No. 1
Simon & Schuster. (2002).
Handbook for Writers
. Ed. Lynn Quitman Troyka, , NJ:
Upper Saddle River , Prentice Hall.
Zakahi,Walter.(1988).
Communication Education
. West Virginia: Speech
Communication Press.